| 1966 | Bromley, Doug | Tennis | Harvard University |
| 1971 | Cates, Marc | Baseball | West Point |
| 1971 | Lockwood, Paul | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 1972 | Algeo, Tom | Football | Dartmouth College |
| 1972 | Edwards, Jim | Football | University of Pennsylvania |
| 1974 | Jackson, David | Soccer | Sewanee - The University Of The South |
| 1974 | Kunkel, Harold | Tennis | Drury University |
| 1975 | Terry, Kyle | Baseball | Vanderbilt University |
| 1976 | Glendening, Robb | Baseball | University of Oklahoma |
| 1976 | Jackson, Peter | Soccer | Knox College |
| 1976 | Patterson, Cip | Basketball | Oral Roberts University |
| 1976 | Nunn, Wally | Major League Baseball | Philadelphia Phillies |
| 1977 | Foyil, Tom | Football | Wichita State University |
| 1977 | Kunkel, Cheryl | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| 1977 | Meyer, Greg | Baseball | Texas Christian University |
| 1977 | Tennant II, Melvin | Track & Field | Rice University |
| 1978 | Boswell, Douglas | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| 1978 | Condry, Mark | Baseball | West Point |
| 1978 | McKnight, Lisa | Soccer | Smith College |
| 1979 | Barnard, Katherine | Basketball | Rice University |
| 1978 | Eaton, Pam | Crew | Yale University |
| 1978 | Powers, Phil | Soccer | Hobart College |
| 1978 | Strange, Susan | Track & Field | University of Tulsa |
| 1978 | Webb, Jan | Volleyball | Oral Roberts University |
| 1980 | Thurman, Donald | Baseball | Dartmouth College |
| 1981 | Bloodgood, Pamela | Cross Country | University of Michigan |
| 1981 | Dreyer, Mark | Basketball | Washington University - St. Louis |
| 1981 | Eaton, Alex | Football | University of Redlands |
| 1981 | Shaw, Gevin | Cross Country | Washington University |
| 1981 | Weber, Ashley | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| 1981 | Woffard, Tim | Baseball | University of Arkansas |
| 1982 | Henson, Bill | Basketball | Trinity University |
| 1982 | Moore, Laura | Gymnastics | Oklahoma State University |
| 1982 | Robinson, Alan | Baseball | Baker University |
| 1982 | Sparks, Steve | Baseball | Sam Houston University |
| 1982 | Wyant, Jim | Volleyball | Carlton College |
| 1983 | Allen, Doug | Cross Country | Yale University |
| 1983 | Clark, Tim | Football/Baseball | University of Missouri |
| 1983 | Hosterman, Jack | Football | Washington University |
| 1983 | Torgerson, Robert | Swimming | Vanderbilt University |
| 1983 | Wolfe, Gregory | Baseball | Stanford University |
| 1984 | Chitwood, Ami | Field Hockey | Stanford University |
| 1984 | Clark, Toby | Soccer/Tennis | Principia College |
| 1984 | Gallagher, Karen | Cross Country | American University |
| 1984 | Hicks, Mike | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 1984 | Hosterman, Clay | Basketball | Trinity University |
| 1984 | Lunnon, Barry | Baseball | Wichita State University |
| 1984 | McCartney, Jill | Soccer | University of North Carolina |
| 1984 | Poulet, Chris | Cross Country | University of Tulsa |
| 1984 | Ramey, Darren | Golf | Westminster College |
| 1984 | Ward, Nancy | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 1985 | Reynolds, Greg | Football | Swathmore College |
| 1986 | Blechner, Douglas | Soccer | University of North Carolina |
| 1986 | Daugherty, Anne | Field Hockey | Wooster College |
| 1986 | Farley, Mike | Football | Yale University |
| 1986 | Motley, Herman | Basketball | Langston University |
| 1986 | Scott, David | Football | Washington University |
| 1987 | Gross, Tag | Football | University of Kansas |
| 1987 | Lorton, Bobby | Football | University of Colorado |
| 1987 | Miers, Mike | Football | Baylor University |
| 1988 | Beynet, Michelle | Field Hockey | Stanford University |
| 1988 | Blocker, Jacqueline | Track & Field | Harvard University |
| 1988 | Byers, Brent | Golf | Texas Christian University |
| 1988 | Ham, Karen | Soccer | University of Tulsa |
| 1988 | Lewis, Jeff | Football | Bowdoin College |
| 1988 | Matheson, Mark | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 1988 | Matthews, Kevinn | Football | Brown/Cornell |
| 1988 | Smith, Foster | Golf | Vanderbilt University |
| 1988 | Wohlgemuth, Jay | Crew | Harvard University |
| 1989 | Beck, Hilary | Soccer | Brigham Young University |
| 1989 | Collins, Stephanie | Field Hockey | Skidmore College |
| 1989 | Gross, Leslie | Swimming | University of Indiana |
| 1989 | Hudson, Jason | Cross Country | Wooster College |
| 1989 | Huston, Steve | Football/Baseball | Brown University |
| 1990 | Beynet, Danielle | Field Hockey | Stanford University |
| 1990 | Ham, Kyle | Cross Country | DePauw University |
| 1990 | Harmon, Brian | Track & Field | University of Tulsa |
| 1990 | Nelson, Ryan | Football | Oklahoma State University |
| 1990 | Percy, Jason | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 1990 | Thompson, Jamie | Field Hockey | Sweet Briar College |
| 1990 | Watts, Jeff | Track & Field | Southern Methodist University |
| 1991 | Bromley, Jeannie | Soccer | University of Colorado |
| 1991 | Davis, Christy | Tennis | Texas Tech University |
| 1991 | Haskin, Niki | Soccer | Mercer University |
| 1991 | Henry, Brooks | Football | Trinity University |
| 1991 | Hyden, Brooke | Soccer | Franklin & Marshall College |
| 1991 | Lee, Denny | Soccer | DePauw University |
| 1991 | Luitwieler, Kurt | Track/Soccer | Carnegie Mellon University |
| 1991 | Rainwater, Ryan | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 1991 | Todd, David | Football | Bucknell University |
| 1991 | Vo, Chau | Track | University of Tulsa |
| 1992 | Bagwell, Johnny | Football | Rice University |
| 1992 | Beck, Amanda | Soccer | Brigham Young University |
| 1992 | Butler, Robbie | Football | Washington University - St. Louis |
| 1992 | Franden, Meredith | Field Hockey | University of Michigan |
| 1992 | Greer, Jon | Baseball | Texas Christian University |
| 1992 | Klos, Kevin | Basketball | Trinity University |
| 1992 | Rhoades, Rachel | Field Hockey | Ohio State University |
| 1992 | Slicker, Laura | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| 1992 | Utter, Christy | Field Hockey | University of North Carolina |
| 1992 | Utter, Jeff | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 1992 | Ward, Craig | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 1993 | Aaronson, Michael | Football | Rice University |
| 1993 | Colessides, Lexi | Soccer | Boston College |
| 1993 | Hawkins, Scott | Football/Baseball | Colorado College |
| 1993 | Honeybone, Andrew | Tennis | Trinity University |
| 1993 | Jones, Jennifer | Soccer | Texas A&M University |
| 1993 | Tucker, Trent | Tennis | University of Kansas |
| 1994 | Bromley, Amy | Soccer | University of Indiana |
| 1994 | Ertugrul, Ty | Soccer | University of Evansville |
| 1994 | Francy, David | Soccer | Rhodes College |
| 1994 | Meade, Justin | Soccer | Colorado College |
| 1995 | Benyet, David | Tennis | Yale University |
| 1995 | Fleming, Parker | Cross Country | Wake Forest University |
| 1995 | Matheson, Derek | Baseball | University of Arkansas |
| 1995 | Savage, Damon | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 1995 | Slicker, Kipp | Baseball | University of Connecticut |
| 1996 | Bishop, Mandy | Basketball | University of San Diego |
| 1996 | Chambers, Mallory | Field Hockey | Stanford University |
| 1996 | DePass, Brian | Football | William Jewell College |
| 1996 | Jones, Kyle | Golf | Oral Roberts University |
| 1996 | Rodgers, Chad | Basketball | University of Tulsa |
| 1996 | Sommer, Tyler | Soccer | Penn State University |
| 1997 | Brakhage, Cyan | Tennis | Colgate University |
| 1997 | Briggs, Ryan | Football | Ripon College |
| 1997 | Ferguson, Jeff | Football | University of Oklahoma |
| 1997 | Hightower, Barret | Field Hockey | Dartmouth College |
| 1997 | McCaslin, Chris | Football | Rhodes College |
| 1997 | McDaniel, Nekia | Field Hockey | Bentley University |
| 1997 | Smith, Adam | Football | Westminster College |
| 1997 | Sommer, Courtney | Field Hockey | Duke University |
| 1997 | Taylor, Shanen | Soccer | William Jewell College |
| 1998 | Coyle, Ryan | Tennis | Yale University |
| 1998 | Dillion, Jeff | Football | Southwestern Oklahoma State University |
| 1998 | Frazier, Monty | Soccer | University of Kentucky |
| 1998 | Greer, Beth | Field Hockey | University of Richmond |
| 1998 | Hightower, Ashley | Field Hockey | Colgate University |
| 1998 | Higgins, Chris | Baseball | Princeton University |
| 1998 | Martin, Melissa | Tennis | William Jewell College |
| 1998 | Rusley, Kate | Soccer | University of Oklahoma |
| 1998 | Sheehan, Trace | Golf | Duke University |
| 1998 | Spencer, Lee | Cross Country | Hendrix College |
| 1998 | Sutton, Oliver | Football | University of Missouri |
| 1998 | Von Glahn, Robert | Football | Carlton College |
| 1998 | Wilson, Denoto | Football | Oklahoma State University |
| 1999 | Adams, Sarah | Field Hockey | University of Richmond |
| 1999 | Bennett, Mark | Cross Country | Hendrix College |
| 1999 | Fleming, Jordan | Soccer | Wofford College |
| 1999 | Jetton, Mark | Football | Lindenwood University |
| 1999 | Jones, Lindsay | Golf | Oral Roberts University |
| 1999 | McDaniel, Chris | Soccer | University of Kentucky |
| 1999 | Roberts, Jennifer A. | Cross Country | Cornell University |
| 1999 | Spencer, Greg | Cross Country/Track | Hendrix College |
| 1999 | Stephenson, J.D. | Soccer | University of Kentucky |
| 1999 | Thrash, Lauryn | Volleyball | Westminster College |
| 1999 | Williams, Chase | Football | University of Oklahoma |
| 2000 | Brown, Courtney | Football | Knox College |
| 2000 | Kerr, Katrina | Field Hockey | University of California |
| 2001 | Barnard, Leslie | Crew | University of Tulsa |
| 2001 | Detwiler, Sarah | Ice Hockey | Utica College |
| 2001 | Green, Jennifer | Basketball | Grayson College |
| 2001 | Helmerich, Erica | Track | University of Oklahoma |
| 2001 | Higgins, Ryan | Baseball | Naval Academy |
| 2001 | Rojas, Tricia | Basketball | Westminster College |
| 2002 | Bundren, Jonathan | Cross Country/Track | Texas Christian University |
| 2002 | Ertugrul, Tolga | Football | Vanderbilt University |
| 2002 | Finkbeiner, Ben | Track & Field | Oral Roberts University |
| 2002 | Roberts, Elizabeth | Soccer | Hamilton College |
| 2002 | Schmalbach, Bryan | Baseball | Texarkana J.C. |
| 2002 | Swartz, Michael | Soccer | Loras College |
| 2003 | Adams, Laura | Soccer | Drury University |
| 2003 | Bunting, Nick | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2003 | Cavert, Matt | Swimming | University of Hawaii |
| 2003 | Crosby, Nathan | Football | Texas Christian University |
| 2003 | Gibson, Clayton | Football | Harvard University |
| 2003 | Harkreader, Jack | Baseball | Independence C.C. |
| 2003 | Herd, Jess | Football | Westminster College |
| 2003 | Honeycutt, Kip | Baseball | St. Gregory's University |
| 2003 | Mamalis, Christina | Rowing/Crew | University of Tulsa |
| 2003 | Rucker, Rickki | Basketball | North Texas State University |
| 2003 | Tollett, Michael | Baseball | Pratt C.C. |
| 2003 | Yates, Sarah | Softball | Trinity University |
| 2004 | Armstrong, Andrew | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2004 | Augsburger, Greg | Football/Baseball | Trinity University |
| 2004 | Butler, Justin | Football | University of Missouri - Rolla |
| 2004 | Bundren, Shelly | Cross Country | Cornell University |
| 2004 | Emel, Zach | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2004 | Gray, Will | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| 2004 | Martin, Julie | Tennis | Vanderbilt University |
| 2004 | Orr, Chelsea | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 2004 | Ritter, Paulius | Basketball | Southern Methodist University |
| 2004 | Woodard, Robbie | Football | University of Missouri - Rolla |
| 2005 | Alame, James | Basketball | Pittsburg State University |
| 2005 | Allen, Scott | Soccer | Denver University |
| 2005 | Begnel, Terrence | Golf | Midland Junior College |
| 2005 | Banas, Katherine | Field Hockey | Radford College |
| 2005 | Briggs, Olivia | Rowing | Oklahoma City University |
| 2005 | Hawkins, Lee Allen | Basketball | Westminster College |
| 2005 | Kranz, Zach | Football | Princeton University |
| 2005 | Owens, John | Football | DePauw University |
| 2005 | Wright, Coby | Baseball | Coffeyville Junior College |
| 2006 | Detwiler, Alex | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2007 | Adwon, Mitch | Football | Princeton University |
| 2007 | Bibens, Robert | Cross Country/Track | Drury University |
| 2007 | Connughton, Philip | Track & Field | Providence University |
| 2007 | Gates, Nick | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2007 | Gray, Kristen | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 2007 | Hawkins, Adam | Football | DePauw University |
| 2007 | Knight, Ryan | Basketball | James Madison |
| 2007 | Lamson, Drew | Baseball | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| 2007 | Morrow, Jack | Cross Country/Track | University of Pittsburg |
| 2007 | Rogers, Ronan | Football | West Point |
| 2007 | Smith, Burris | Football | DePauw University |
| 2007 | Spencer, John | Cross Country/Track | Greenville College |
| 2007 | Sweeney, Jake | Track & Field | DePauw University |
| 2007 | White, Chris | Baseball | DePauw University |
| 2007 | Woodard, Ryan | Football | DePauw University |
| 2007 | Wright, Ashley | Track | Trinity University |
| 2008 | Allen, Matt | Football | Princeton University |
| 2008 | Bach, Hillary | Softball | Arizona State University |
| 2008 | Boettcher, Lily | Golf | Yale University |
| 2008 | Frey, Max | Tennis | Trinity University |
| 2008 | Hutton, Brig | Baseball | Rogers State College |
| 2008 | Johnson, Kevin | Track & Field | University of Arkansas |
| 2008 | Miller, Paige | Track & Field | University of Tulsa |
| 2008 | Redeagle, Braxton | Football | Sewanne - The University Of The South |
| 2008 | Smith, Brendan | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2008 | Smith, Steven | Baseball | Rogers State College |
| 2008 | Tapper, Katie | Soccer | Tufts University |
| 2009 | Cartens, Emily | Crew | Southern Methodist University |
| 2009 | Craven, Conley | Field Hockey | University of California - Davis |
| 2009 | Frazier, Julian | Track & Field | University of Tulsa |
| 2009 | Hedman, Seth | Football | Drake University |
| 2009 | Helmerich, Zac | Football | Trinity College |
| 2009 | Lamson, Nikki | Track & Field | Babson College |
| 2009 | Lenora, Ian | Football | Washington & Lee |
| 2009 | Mask, Denny | Soccer | UNC Greensboro/Trinity University |
| 2009 | Neely, Andrew | Football | Kenyon College |
| 2009 | Phipps, Will | Soccer | Evergreen State University |
| 2009 | Stahl, Joe | Soccer | Brown University |
| 2009 | Stewart, Sid | Soccer | University of Tulsa |
| 2009 | Smith, Amanda | Soccer | Baker College |
| 2009 | Sweeney, Luke | Football | Pomona College |
| 2009 | Waugh, Camron | Football | Hamilton College |
| 2009 | Wright, Jon | Soccer | Memphis University |
| 2010 | Adwon, Amanda | Field Hockey | University of Michigan |
| 2010 | Brady, Maggie | Field Hockey | Brown University |
| 2010 | Clary, Grant | Track & Field | DePauw University |
| 2010 | Cronk, Jules | Baseball | Trinity University |
| 2010 | Hauge, Lauren | Field Hockey | University of Michigan |
| 2010 | Hicks, Chandler | Football | Trinity University |
| 2010 | Hood, Natalie | Field Hockey | St. Louis University |
| 2010 | Justice, Mason | Baseball | Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College |
| 2010 | Powers, Natalie | Softball | University of Tennessee - Chattanooga |
| 2010 | Randall, Joe | Basketball | Covenant College |
| 2010 | Steele, Emma | Track & Field | Dartmouth College |
| 2010 | White, Nick | Track & Field/Football | DePauw University |
| 2011 | Bayliss, Christina | Basketball | Rockhurst University |
| 2011 | Frizzell, Luke | Lacrosse | Virginia Military Institute |
| 2011 | Hart, Tommy | Soccer | Duke University |
| 2011 | Joyce, Andrea | Rowing | University of Kansas |
| 2011 | Kragthorpe, Brad | Football | Idaho State University/LSU |
| 2011 | LaFortune, Billy | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2011 | Miles, Bailey | Baseball | Furman University |
| 2011 | Moult, Taylor | Cross Country/Track | Texas Christian University |
| 2011 | Nunn, Grant | Baseball | Hendrix College |
| 2011 | Sexton, Kwame | Football | University of Tulsa/Sterling College |
| 2011 | Starker, Quinn | Soccer | University of Tulsa |
| 2011 | Tisdale, William | Basketball | Southwestern College (Kansas) |
| 2011 | Thompson, Will | Football | Washington University - St. Louis |
| 2012 | Bulak, Arda | Football | University of Puget Sound |
| 2012 | Carmichael, Jenny | Track & Field | University of Oklahoma |
| 2012 | Chastang, Amanda | Softball | DePauw University |
| 2012 | Hicks, Claire | Volleyball | Austin College |
| 2012 | Jefferson, Sophie | Volleyball | University of Central Oklahoma |
| 2012 | McCarver, Eryn | Softball | University of Utah |
| 2012 | Saliba, Cindy | Cross Country/Track | University of Iowa |
| 2012 | Townsend, Jules | Softball | University of Oklahoma |
| 2012 | Townsend, Paris | Softball | University of Oklahoma |
| 2013 | Adelson, Caroline | Track and Field | Cornell University |
| 2013 | Bayliss, Matt | Football | University of Texas - San Antonio |
| 2013 | Best, Erin | Field Hockey | Rhodes College |
| 2013 | Buchannan, Jackson | Soccer | Harding University |
| 2013 | Celoni, Erika | Soccer | Rockhurst University |
| 2013 | Craven, Bridge | Football | Trinity University |
| 2013 | Gray, Sam | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 2013 | Sexton, Jordan | Football | Bethany College |
| 2013 | Solomon, Grayson | Football | Gettysburg College |
| 2013 | Stewart, Nate | Soccer | Long Island University |
| 2013 | White, Phillip | Soccer | Harding University |
| 2014 | Arnold, Kelsey | Softball | University of Oklahoma |
| 2014 | Brady, Pierce | Football | Kenyon College |
| 2014 | Calhoun, Payton | Softball | Northern Oklahoma College |
| 2014 | Eaton, James | Football | Cornell University |
| 2014 | Gilbert, Madi | Field Hockey | Siena College |
| 2014 | Gross, Cooper | Football | Austin College |
| 2014 | Harjo, Luke | Baseball | Rhodes College |
| 2014 | McGregor, Micaela | Track & Field | Cornell University |
| 2014 | Nelson, JT | Soccer | Belmont University |
| 2014 | Oyekan, Anthony | Track & Field | University of Missouri - KC |
| 2014 | Parker, Michael | Soccer | Belmont University |
| 2014 | Taylor, Amaris | Field Hockey | Southern New Hampshire University |
| 2015 | Bezhan, Anna | Volleyball | Stetson University |
| 2015 | Burke, Matthew | Football | Mid American Nazarene |
| 2015 | Cooks, TJ | Basketball | University of Dallas |
| 2015 | Coons, Parker | Football | Haskell College |
| 2015 | Goddard, Jackson | Baseball | University of Kansas |
| 2015 | Gragg, Avery | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2015 | Klinghagen, Drew | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2015 | Pena, Mercedes | Field Hockey | Colby College |
| 2015 | Reddy, Arjun | Golf | Drake University |
| 2015 | Savage, Ann | Basketball | Austin College |
| 2015 | Springman, Slater | Baseball | Oklahoma Christian University |
| 2015 | Taylor, Corey | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 2016 | Adelson, Elizabeth | Track & Field | Yale University |
| 2016 | Armour, Anthony | Football | Missouri State University |
| 2016 | Atwell, Jessica | Basketball | Austin College |
| 2016 | Byers, Jenna | Soccer | Texas A&M University |
| 2016 | Frizzell, Merich | Field Hockey | Liberty University |
| 2016 | Smith, Tara | Soccer | Texas Christian University |
| 2016 | Sutton, Spencer | Basketball | Oral Roberts University |
| 2016 | Van Hooser, Jake | Golf | Oklahoma City University |
| 2016 | White, Gracie | Field Hockey | DePauw University |
| 2017 | Burke, Mikey | Baseball | Florida Southwestern State College |
| 2017 | Cox, Kennedy | Basketball | Emmanuel College |
| 2017 | Murphy, Maddie | Field Hockey | Slippery Rock University |
| 2017 | Pfannenstiel, Crae | Baseball | Newman University |
| 2017 | Salisbury, Laurel | Crew | University of Kansas |
| 2017 | Thompson, CJ | Football | Fort Hays State University/South Alabama University |
| 2017 | Thompson, Summer | Track & Field | Oklahoma State University |
| 2017 | Wang, Krystal | Volleyball | Case Western Reserve University |
| 2017 | White, Casey | Baseball | Hesston College |
| 2017 | Williamson, Cooper | Golf | Wheaton College |
| 2017 | Wise, Annie | Basketball/Tennis | Trinity University |
| 2018 | Arnold, Darin | Football | NEO A&M College |
| 2018 | Daniels, Corbin | Football | NEO A&M College |
| 2018 | Hicks, Olivia | Track & Field | Tulane University |
| 2018 | McConnell, Bryce | Track & Field | Oklahoma City University |
| 2018 | Ostroski, Jackson | Football | Drake University |
| 2018 | Smith, Joe | Football | NEO A&M College |
| 2019 | Atherton, Jack | Tennis | University of Nevada - Las Vegas |
| 2019 | Clark, Toby | Football | Washington University - St. Louis |
| 2019 | Felkins, Alex | Football | Columbia University |
| 2019 | Gregory, Gabby | Basketball | University of Oklahoma |
| 2019 | Jennings, Jack | Lacrosse | Hamilton College |
| 2019 | LaFortune, Johnny | Cross Country/Track | Middlebury College |
| 2019 | LaTurno, Bethany | Volleyball | Ouachita Baptist University |
| 2019 | McClure, Caden | Baseball | Amherst College |
| 2019 | Mullendore, Vance | Football | Oklahoma State University |
| 2019 | Terry, Lauryn | Volleyball | Clark Atlanta University |
| 2020 | Bowers, Daniel | Football | Drake University |
| 2020 | Davis, Brock | Basketball | Morehouse College |
| 2020 | Radford, Hailey | Field Hockey | DePauw University |
| 2020 | Sanders, Mac | Cross Country/Track | Haverford College |
