| 1966 | Doug Bromley | Tennis | Harvard |
| 1971 | Marc Cates | Baseball | West Point |
| Paul Lockwood | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 1972 | Tom Algeo | Football | Dartmouth |
| Jim Edwards | Football | University of Pennsylvania |
| 1974 | David Jackson | Soccer | Sewanee |
| Harold Kunkel | Tennis | Drury |
| 1975 | Kyle Terry | Baseball | Vanderbilt |
| 1976 | Cip Patterson | Basketball | Oral Roberts University |
| Robb Glendening | Baseball | University of Oklahoma |
| Peter Jackson | Soccer | Knox |
| Wally Nunn | Major League Baseball | Philadelphia Phillies |
| 1977 | Greg Meyer | Baseball | Texas Christian University |
| Tom Foyil | Football | Wichita State University |
| Cheryl Kunkel | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| Melvin Tennant, II | Track | Rice University |
| 1978 | Douglas Boswell | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| Mark Condry | Baseball | West Point |
| Lisa McKnight | Soccer | Smith College |
| 1979 | Katherine Barnard | Basketball | Rice University |
| Phil Powers | Soccer | Hobart College |
| Susan Strange | Track | University of Tulsa |
| Jan Webb | Volleyball | Oral Roberts University |
| Pam Eaton | Crew | Yale |
| 1980 | Donald Thurman | Baseball | Dartmouth |
| 1981 | Alex Eaton | Football | University of Redlands |
| Pamela Bloodgood | Cross Country | University of Michigan |
| Mark Dreyer | Basketball | Washington University – St. Louis |
| Gevin Shaw | Cross Country | Washington University |
| Ashley Weber | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| Tim Woffard | Baseball | University of Arkansas |
| 1982 | Bill Henson | Basketball | Trinity University |
| Laura Moore | Gymnastics | Oklahoma State University |
| Alan Robinson | Baseball | Baker University |
| Steve Sparks | Baseball | Sam Houston University |
| Jim Wyant | Volleyball | Carlton College |
| 1983 | Tim Clark | Football/Baseball | University of Missouri |
| Jack Hosterman | Football | Washington University |
| Robert Torgerson | Swimming | Vanderbilt |
| Gregory Wolfe | Baseball | Stanford |
| Doug Allen | Cross Country | Yale |
| 1984 | Karen Gallagher | Cross Country | American University |
| Ami Chitwood | Field Hockey | Stanford |
| Toby Clark | Soccer/Tennis | Principia |
| Mike Hicks | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Clay Hosterman | Basketball | Trinity University |
| Barry Lunnon | Baseball | Wichita State University |
| Jill McCartney | Soccer | University of North Carolina |
| Nancy Ward | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| Chris Poulet | Cross Country | University of Tulsa |
| Darren Ramey | Golf | Westminster College |
| 1985 | Greg Reynolds | Football | Swathmore |
| 1986 | Douglas Blechner | Soccer | University of North Carolina |
| Mike Farley | Football | Yale |
| David Scott | Football | Washington University |
| Anne Daugherty | Field Hockey | Wooster College |
| Herman Motley | Basketball | Langston University |
| 1987 | Tag Gross | Football | University of Kansas |
| Bobby Lorton | Football | University of Colorado |
| Mike Miers | Football | Baylor University |
| 1988 | Mark Matheson | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Kevinn Matthews | Football | Brown/Cornell |
| Jay Wohlgemuth | Crew | Harvard |
| Jeff Lewis | Football | Bowdoin |
| Jacqueline Blocker | Track | Harvard |
| Foster Smith | Golf | Vanderbilt |
| Brent Byers | Golf | Texas Christian University |
| Michelle Beynet | Field Hockey | Stanford |
| Karen Ham | Soccer | University of Tulsa |
| 1989 | Steve Huston | Football/Baseball | Brown University |
| Jason Hudson | Cross Country | Wooster College |
| Leslie Gross | Swimming | University of Indiana |
| Stephanie Collins | Field Hockey | Skidmore |
| Hilary Beck | Soccer | Brigham Young University |
| 1990 | Jamie Thompson | Field Hockey | Sweetbriar |
| Danielle Beynet | Field Hockey | Stanford |
| Kyle Ham | Cross Country | DePauw University |
| Ryan Nelson | Football | Oklahoma State University |
| Jeff Watts | Track | Southern Methodist University |
| Jason Percy | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Brian Harmon | Track | University of Tulsa |
| 1991 | Brooks Henry | Football | Trinity University |
| Denny Lee | Soccer | DePauw College |
| Kurt Luitwieler | Track/Soccer | Carnegie Mellon |
| David Todd | Football | Bucknell |
| Ryan Rainwater | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| Christy Davis | Tennis | Texas Tech University |
| Jeannie Bromley | Soccer | University of Colorado |
| Brooke Hyden | Soccer | Franklin & Marshall |
| Chau Vo | Track | University of Tulsa |
| Niki Haskin | Soccer | Mercer University |
| 1992 | Johnny Bagwell | Football | Rice University |
| Robbie Butler | Football | Washington University |
| Laura Slicker | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| Jeff Utter | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Jon Greer | Baseball | Texas Christian University |
| Amanda Beck | Soccer | Brigham Young University |
| Kevin Klos | Basketball | Trinity University |
| Meredith Franden | Field Hockey | University of Michigan |
| Rachel Rhoades | Field Hockey | Ohio State University |
| Christy Utter | Field Hockey | University of North Carolina |
| Craig Ward | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| 1993 | Michael Aaronson | Football | Rice University |
| Andrew Honeybone | Tennis | Trinity University |
| Trent Tucker | Tennis | University of Kansas |
| Jennifer Jones | Soccer | Texas A & M |
| Lexi Colessides | Soccer | Boston College |
| Scott Hawkins | Football/Baseball | Colorado College |
| 1994 | David Francy | Soccer | Rhodes College |
| Amy Bromley | Soccer | University of Indiana |
| Ty Ertugrul | Soccer | University of Evansville |
| Justin Meade | Soccer | Colorado College |
| 1995 | Kipp Slicker | Baseball | University of Connecticut |
| Parker Fleming | Cross Country | Wake Forest |
| David Benyet | Tennis | Yale |
| Derek Matheson | Baseball | University of Arkansas |
| Damon Savage | Football | University of Tulsa |
| 1996 | Mandy Bishop | Basketball | University of San Diego |
| Mallory Chambers | Field Hockey | Stanford |
| Brian DePass | Football | William Jewell |
| Kyle Jones | Golf | Oral Roberts University |
| Tyler Sommer | Soccer | Penn State University |
| Chad Rodgers | Basketball | University of Tulsa |
| 1997 | Courtney Sommer | Field Hockey | Duke |
| Ryan Briggs | Football | Ripon College |
| Cyan Brakhage | Tennis | Colgate |
| Shanen Taylor | Soccer | William Jewell |
| Adam Smith | Football | Westminster College |
| Chris McCaslin | Football | Rhodes |
| Jeff Ferguson | Football | University of Oklahoma |
| Barret Hightower | Field Hockey | Dartmouth |
| Nekia McDaniel | Field Hockey | Bentley University |
| 1998 | Ryan Coyle | Tennis | Yale |
| Jeff Dillion | Football | Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Monty Frazier | Soccer | University of Kentucky |
| Beth Greer | Field Hockey | University of Richmond |
| Lee Spencer | Cross Country | Hendrix College |
| Oliver Sutton | Football | University of Missouri |
| Robert Von Glahn | Football | Carlton College |
| Denoto Wilson | Football | Oklahoma State University |
| Trace Sheehan | Golf | Duke |
| Kate Rusley | Soccer | University of Oklahoma |
| Chris Higgins | Baseball | Princeton |
| Melissa Martin | Tennis | William Jewell |
| Ashley Hightower | Field Hockey | Colgate |
| 1999 | J.D. Stephenson | Soccer | University of Kentucky |
| Chris McDaniel | Soccer | University of Kentucky |
| Mark Bennett | Cross Country | Hendrix College |
| Chase Williams | Football | University of Oklahoma |
| Mark Jetton | Football | Lindenwood |
| Sarah Adams | Field Hockey | University of Richmond |
| Lauryn Thrash | Volleyball | Westminster College |
| Jordan Fleming | Soccer | Wofford College |
| Jennifer A. Roberts | Cross Country | Cornell |
| Greg Spencer | Cross Country/Track | Hendrix College |
| Lindsay Jones | Golf | Oral Roberts University |
| 2000 | Courtney Brown | Football | Knox |
| Katrina Kerr | Field Hockey | University of California |
| 2001 | Jennifer Green | Basketball | Grayson |
| Sarah Detwiler | Ice Hockey | Utica College |
| Ryan Higgins | Baseball | Naval Academy |
| Leslie Barnard | Crew | University of Tulsa |
| Erica Helmerich | Track | University of Oklahoma |
| Tricia Rojas | Basketball | Westminster College |
| 2002 | Jonathan Bundren | Cross Country | Texas Christian University |
| Tolga Ertugrul | Football | Vanderbilt |
| Ben Finkbeiner | Track | Oral Roberts University |
| Elizabeth Roberts | Soccer | Hamilton College |
| Bryan Schmalbach | Baseball | Texarkana J.C. |
| Michael Swartz | Soccer | Loras College |
| 2003 | Laura Adams | Soccer | Drury |
| Nick Bunting | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Nathan Crosby | Football | Texas Christian University |
| Alex Detwiler | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Kip Honeycutt | Baseball | St. Gregory’s University |
| Rickki Rucker | Basketball | North Texas State University |
| Michael Tollett | Baseball | Pratt C.C. |
| Sarah Yates | Softball | Trinity University |
| Matt Cavert | Swimming | University of Hawaii |
| Jack Harkreader | Baseball | Independence C.C. |
| Clayton Gibson | Football | Harvard |
| Christina Mamalis | Rowing/Crew | University of Tulsa |
| Jess Herd | Football | Westminster College |
| 2004 | Andrew Armstrong | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Greg Augsburger | Football/Baseball | Trinity University |
| Justin Butler | Football | University of Missouri, Rolla |
| Shelly Bundren | Cross Country | Cornell |
| Zach Emel | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Will Gray | Tennis | University of Tulsa |
| Julie Martin | Tennis | Vanderbilt |
| Chelsea Orr | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| Paulius Ritter | Basketball | Southern Methodist University |
| Robbie Woodard | Football | University of Missouri, Rolla |
| 2005 | James Alame | Basketball | Pittsburg State University |
| Scott Allen | Soccer | Denver University |
| Terrence Begnel | Golf | Midland Junior College |
| Katherine Banas | Field Hockey | Radford College |
| Olivia Briggs | Rowing | Oklahoma City University |
| Lee Allen Hawkins | Basketball | Westminster College |
| Zach Kranz | Football | Princeton University |
| John Owens | Football | DePauw University |
| Coby Wright | Baseball | Coffeyville Junior College |
| 2007 | Ronan Rogers | Football | Army |
| Ashley Wright | Track | Trinity University |
| Jack Morrow | Cross Country/Track | Pittsburg |
| Nick Gates | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Mitch Adwon | Football | Princeton |
| Adam Hawkins | Football | DePauw University |
| Chris White | Baseball | DePauw University |
| Burris Smith | Football | DePauw University |
| Ryan Woodard | Football | DePauw University |
| Robert Bibens | Cross Country/Track | Drury |
| Kristen Gray | Tennis | University of Oklahoma |
| Philip Connughton | Track | Providence |
| John Spencer | Cross Country/Track | Greenville College |
| Jake Sweeney | Track | DePauw University |
| Drew Lamson | Baseball | M.I.T. |
| Ryan Knight | Basketball | James Madison |
| 2008 | Matt Allen | Football | Princeton |
| Hillary Bach | Softball | Arizona State University |
| Lily Boettcher | Golf | Yale |
| Max Frey | Tennis | Trinity University |
| Brig Hutton | Baseball | Rogers State College |
| Kevin Johnson | Track & Field | University of Arkansas |
| Drew Keenan | Baseball | Juco |
| Paige Miller | Track & Field | University of Tulsa |
| Braxton Redeagle | Football | Sewanee |
| Brendan Smith | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Steven Smith | Baseball | Rogers State College |
| Katie Tapper | Soccer | Tufts |
| 2009 | Emily Cartens | Crew | Southern Methodist University |
| Conley Craven | Field Hockey | UC-Davis |
| Julian Frazier | Track & Field | University of Tulsa |
| Nikki Lamson | Track & Field | Babson College |
| Denny Mask | Soccer | Trinity University |
| Jon Wright | Soccer | Memphis University |
| Joe Stahl | Soccer | Brown University |
| Sid Stewart | Soccer | University of Tulsa |
| Amanda Smith | Soccer | Baker College |
| Will Phipps | Soccer | Evergreen State University |
| Seth Hedman | Football | Drake University |
| Camron Waugh | Football | Hamilton College |
| Zac Helmerich | Football | Trinity College |
| Andrew Neely | Football | Kenyon College |
| Luke Sweeney | Football | Pomona College |
| Ian Lenora | Football | Washington & Lee |
| 2010 | Amanda Adwon | Field Hockey | University of Michigan |
| Maggie Brady | Field Hockey | Brown University |
| Grant Clary | Track & Field | Michigan State University |
| Jules Cronk | Baseball | Trinity College |
| Lauren Hauge | Field Hockey | University of Michigan |
| Chandler Hicks | Football | Trinity College |
| Natalie Hood | Field Hockey | St. Louis University |
| Mason Justice | Baseball | Eastern A & M |
| Natalie Powers | Softball | University of Tennessee,Chattanooga |
| Joe Randall | Basketball | Covenant College |
| Emma Steele | Track & Field | Dartmouth |
| Nick White | Track & Field/Football | DePauw University |
| 2011 | Christina Bayliss | Basketball | Rockhurst |
| Luke Frizzell | Lacrosse | VMI |
| Tommy Hart | Soccer | Duke |
| Andrea Joyce | Rowing | Kansas |
| Brad Kragthorpe | Football | Idaho State |
| Billy LaFortune | Football | Tulsa |
| Bailey Miles | Baseball | Furman |
| Taylor Moult | Cross Country | Texas Christian University |
| Grant Nunn | Baseball | Hendrix College |
| Kwame Sexton | Football | Tulsa |
| Quinn Starker | Soccer | Tulsa |
| William Tisdale | Basketball | Southwestern College (Kansas) |
| Will Thompson | Football | Washington University |
| 2012 | Arda Bulak | Football | Puget Sound |
| Jenny Carmichael | Track & Field | Oklahoma |
| Amanda Chastang | Softball | DePauw |
| Claire Hicks | Volleyball | Austin College |
| Sophie Jefferson | Volleyball | Central Oklahoma |
| Eryn McCarver | Softball | Utah |
| Cindy Saliba | Cross Country/Track | Iowa |
| Jules Townsend | Softball | Oklahoma |
| Paris Townsend | Softball | Oklahoma |
| 2013 | Caroline Adelson | Track and Field | Cornell |
| Matt Bayliss | Football | UT-San Antonio |
| Erin Best | Field Hockey | Rhodes College |
| Jackson Buchannan | Soccer | Harding |
| Erika Celoni | Soccer | Rockhurst |
| Bridge Craven | Football | Trinity University |
| Sam Gray | Tennis | Oklahoma |
| Jordan Sexton | Football | Bethany College |
| Grayson Solomon | Football | Gettysburg College |
| Nate Stewart | Soccer | Long Island University |
| Phillip White | Soccer | Harding |
| 2014 | Kelsey Arnold | Softball | University of Oklahoma |
| Pierce Brady | Football | Kenyon College |
| John Byers | Baseball | University of Oklahoma |
| Payton Calhoun | Softball | Northern Oklahoma College |
| James Eaton | Football | Cornell University |
| Madi Gilbert | Field Hockey | Siena College |
| Cooper Gross | Football | Austin College |
| Luke Harjo | Baseball | Rhodes College |
| Micaela McGregor | Track & Field | Cornell University |
| JT Nelson | Soccer | Belmont University |
| Anthony Oyekan | Track & Field | University of Missouri – KC |
| Michael Parker | Soccer | Belmont University |
| Amaris Taylor | Field Hockey | Southern New Hampshire University |
| 2015 | Anna Bezhan | Volleyball | Stetson University |
| Matthew Burke | Football | Mid American Nazarene |
| TJ Cooks | Basketball | University of Dallas |
| Parker Coons | Football | Haskell College |
| Jackson Goddard | Baseball | University of Kansas |
| Avery Gragg | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Drew Klinghagen | Football | University of Tulsa |
| Mercedes Pena | Field Hockey | Colby College |
| Arjun Reddy | Golf | Drake University |
| Ann Savage | Basketball | Austin College |
| Slater Springman | Baseball | Oklahoma Christian |
| Corey Taylor | Football | United States Air Force Academy |
| 2016 | Elizabeth Adelson | Track & Field | Yale |
| Anthony Armour | Football | Missouri State University |
| Jessica Atwell | Basketball | Austin College |
| Jenna Byers | Soccer | Texas A&M |
| Merich Frizzell | Field Hockey | Liberty University |
| Tara Smith | Soccer | Texas Christian University |
| Spencer Sutton | Basketball | Oral Roberts University |
| Jake Van Hooser | Golf | Oklahoma City University |
| Gracie White | Field Hockey | DePauw University |
| 2017 | Mikey Burke | Baseball | Florida Southwestern |
| Kennedy Cox | Basetball | Emmanuel College |
| Maddie Murphy | Field Hockey | Slippery Rock |
| Crae Pfannenstiel | Baseball | Newman University |
| CJ Thompson | Football | Fort Hays State |
| Summer Thompson | Track & Field | Oklahoma State University |
| Krystal Wang | Volleyball | Case Western |
| Casey White | Baseball | Hesston College |
| Cooper Williamson | Golf | Wheaton College |
| Annie Wise | Basketball/Tennis | Trinity University |
| 2018 | Darin Arnold | Football | NEO A&M College |
| Corbin Daniels | Football | NEO A&M College |
| Olivia Hicks | Track & Field | Tulane University |
| Bryce McConnell | Track & Field | Oklahoma City University |
| Jackson Ostroski | Football | Drake University |
| Joe Smith | Football | NEO A&M College |
| 2019 | Jack Atherton | Tennis | UNLV |
| Toby Clark | Football | Washington University- St. Louis |
| Alex Felkins | Football | Columbia University |
| Gabby Gregory | Basketball | University of Oklahoma |
| Jack Jennings | Lacrosse | Hamilton College |
| Johnny LaFortune | Cross Country/Track | Middlebury College |
| Bethany LaTurno | Volleyball | Fort Scott |
| Caden McClure | Baseball | Amherst College |
| Vance Mullendore | Football | Oklahoma State University |
| Lauryn Terry | Volleyball | Clark Andrew |
